WAS IT A MISTAKE TO WRITE HAMLET? T.S. Eliot’s rules for literature lead him to some unusual judgments. For example, he concludes that: “CORIOLANUS may be not as “interesting” as HAMLET, but it is, with ANTONY AND CLEOPATRA, Shakespeare’s most assured artistic success.” Eliot winds up by implying that Shakespeare should not have written HAMLET. Not only shouldn’t he have written it, but Eliot finds it baffling that he even tried to attempt it: “We must simply admit that here Shakespeare tackled a problem which proved too much for him. Why he attempted it at all is an insoluble puzzle….” Kids, Eliot’s judgmental approach was not unusual when I was studying literature some fifty years ago. Of the several critics whose essays we were assigned on Milton, all but one (the great C.S. Lewis) thought it was a great mistake for Milton to have written PARADISE LOST.
Categories
Archives
Recent Comments
- ADAPTING GATSBY. (1)
- Mary Jane Schaefer: I think these are crucial, important decisions, what to leave out of any literary work, maybe any...
- DAMIEN HIRST—AN ART MARKET BUBBLE?. (1)
- Kate Bush: I hope you enjoy my visit to the Damien Hirst show as much as I did The Technical Impossibility of...
- THE MOST IMPORTANT EPISODE OF THE SIMPSONS ? (COMMENT). (1)
- Nick: Homer does has success as the team’s best hitter until Mr. Burns places a bet with a rival factory owner...
- THE “RIGHT TO EDIT”. (1)
- Lee: A relevant Simpsons clip.
- ULYSSES—VIRGINIA WOOLF LIKED THE BOOK, DESPISED THE AUTHOR. (3)
- A DEFENSE OF INVASIVE SPECIES. (3)
- Dick Weisfelder: Today’s Toledo Blade has an article on the importation of live Asian carp to Canada to serve...
- Lee: The downside is that red squirrels are way cuter than their gray cousins. Hitchens on the subject.
- THE OLDEST FANTASY BASEBALL LEAGUE STARTS ITS 32ND SEASON. (COMMENT). (5)
- frank martin: Have been in a an Al only Roto league since 91… started at Ohio University were we all went to...
- DEATH OF A BUMBLEBEE. (1)
- Nick: By contrast, I remember witnessing the entire thing. I was surprised by Annalisa’s reaction and...
- ANOTHER VOTE ON UMBRIDGE. (1)
- Dick Weisfelder: When I look back at one of the Potter books, it’s usually this one. There are just a lot of...
- THE SCARIEST VILLAIN IN HARRY POTTER? (1)
- Dick Weisfelder: Didn’t we all meet her somewhere in grade or high school?
- ADAPTING GATSBY. (1)
Meta
In graduate school, we read by assignment a book of essays by T.S. Eliot. I wish I could remember the title. Anyway, I thought it was a terrible book, full of cranky quibbles and totally unenlightening. When I had an interview with my professor, William E. Buckler, I asked him why we were reading this book. Perhaps he took this as a personal attack. His reply was, “Because WE don’t burn books.” At the time I was taken aback by the illogic of this. Now, in retrospect, I think he was just trying to put me in the hot seat where he thought I was putting him. But I had naively thought he would have an answer, what he thought this book was going to contribute to our literary educations. His reply seemed absurb. Were there no alternatives between assigning a book and burning it?
Anyone who wishes that Hamlet had never been written is either jealous, crazy, or both. In this case, probably both.
Jealous, crazy, or perhaps wishing to draw attention to himself.