COUNTERFACTUAL QUESTION: WHAT IF NIXON HAD NOT GONE TO CHINA?

COUNTERFACTUAL QUESTION: WHAT IF NIXON HAD NOT GONE TO CHINA?
Louis Menand has a review in the New Yorker for March 12 of NIXON AND MAO: THE WEEK THAT CHANGED THE WORLD by Margaret MacMillan. The subtitle comes from Nixon’s last toast in Shanghai on his trip to China. Menand says that Nixon’s trip to China “has earned almost universal respect” and that “At the time, the visit to China was often been compared to the landing on the moon….It seemed amazing that the thing could be done at all….” At the time—and now—I would answer the counterfactual question with a shrug. Resuming diplomatic relations between two countries happens all the time. Diplomatic relations are the norm. If Nixon hadn’t restored diplomatic relations, another President would have. And very little more happened besides restoration of diplomatic relations. Menand says, “…the tangible benefits to humankind [of Nixon’s visit] were not self-evident.” I would say that Nixon’s visit was indeed like the landing on the moon in that neither event had much effect on the lives of men.

This entry was posted in History. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to COUNTERFACTUAL QUESTION: WHAT IF NIXON HAD NOT GONE TO CHINA?

  1. Lee says:

    I do think it was important, but I agree that if Nixon had not done it, someone else surely would have. I’d bet that had Nixon and Kissinger not orchestrated the trip he wouldn’t have won his second term. I am glad that there’s trade with China, although a lot of people seem to think this is a bad thing. My African-American Literature professor is sure that the Chinese are predatory boogeymen waiting to become our masters. She states that we “sent” millions of jobs there over the last decade. This rankles me greatly.

  2. Mary Jane says:

    Perhaps I underestimate when all this might have occurred, if Nixon hadn’t done it–but how else could Clinton have “reached out” for Chinese “support” without this diplomatic coup earlier in history? And whatever would the Chinese do without our nuclear “know how”?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *