IS HAMLET FAT? I posted here about reports in the 1960’s that Jackie Gleason might do Hamlet. Kids, Jackie Gleason was a brilliant fat comedian. The caption of my post was: “HAMLET AS A FAT MAN—JACKIE GLEASON.” I have always thought that Gleason would have been very good as Hamlet—which implies that I take for granted that Hamlet can be played by a fat man who is a good actor.

Now, Isaac Butler has raised the question in this article in Slate: “Is Hamlet Fat?” Butler points out that Hamlet is being played right now by Benedict Cumberbatch and has been played by a long line of great slender actors, with the only exceptions being Simon Russell Beale and Paul Giamatti (whose Hamlet I posted on here).

Yet there is a long running debate among scholars and critics that goes beyond the question of whether Hamlet can be played by a fat man. The contention is that—according to the text of the play—Hamlet is in fact fat. Butler says: “During the play’s final sword duel, King Claudius turns to Queen Gertrude and says that Hamlet will win the duel, and Gertrude replies, ‘He’s fat and scant of breath….’”

This entry was posted in Literature, Shakespeare, Theater. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.