THE MYSTERY OF TOM BOMBADIL. Tom Bombadil is controversial. He is the most important character left out of the Lord of the Rings movies. I think that a majority of the Tolkien fans that I know (a small sample) seem to dislike him and are pleased to see him excluded. This wikipedia article gives this description: “Tom Bombadil is a spry fellow, with a quick, playful wit. He speaks in a rhyming whimsical way: ‘Hey dol! merry dol! ring a dong dillo! Ring a dong! hop along! fal lal the willow! Tom Bom, jolly Tom, Tom Bombadillo!’” He goes back to the begining of time. He claims to remember “the first raindrop and the first acorn”, and “knew the dark under the stars when it was fearless — before the Dark Lord came from Outside.” I think that those who don’t like him are influenced by their distaste for his verse. I think I valued him because the hobbits on the quest encounter him early. He sets a tone for the book(s). There are wonders in the world the hobbits have entered and that world has a very long history.
Categories
Archives
Recent Comments
- “TO BE A HEDONIST WITH BAD TASTE…” (1)
- Nick: Perhaps acquiring a taste for expensive wines is not one worth acquiring.
- ORWELL—WRITING SHOULD BE LIKE SPOKEN LANGUAGE. (1)
- Nathaniel: That’s why I can’t text. I’m too much of a writer. It pains me to leave out...
- MARSHALL MCLUHAN AND THE INTERNET. (2)
- HOW BASEBALLS ARE MADE. (2)
- Carl Davidson: Re the video on the making of baseballs, it appears that several parts of the process are done by hand...
- SMALL SAMPLES—ANOTHER PROBLEM WITH PUBLISHED ARTICLES. (2)
- Henry Nejako: Just came across this fascinating New York Magazine article about a 28-year-old graduate student,...
- UMPIRE RATINGS. (4)
- Richard C. Northrup: While watching a game on the MLB network on Wed. 4/17/13, KC vs ATL the home plate umpire...
- MY REACTIONS TO THE HAMLET COMIC STRIP—CONTEMPORARY HAMLETS. (1)
- Barb: Probably Jesus and his disciples…and various writers who shared facts or their own fiction :o) (Sitting...
- THE OLDEST FANTASY BASEBALL LEAGUE STARTS ITS 32ND SEASON. (COMMENT). (6)
- michael gallo: since 1984…..the year the first book came out..stats done by hand when the sporting news arrived
- HOW DID THE ORIOLES DO IT LAST YEAR? (1)
- Nick: And luck can also explain the strong bullpen. The Orioles’ relievers were 9th in the majors in K/BB ratio...
- COMPENSATORY ETHICS—A NEW THEORY OF ETHICS? (1)
- Serhiy: I will not say that people are endowed with different stock of virtue but rather stick to the idea: that some...
- WHAT THE IRISH ATE BEFORE THE COMING OF THE POTATO. (1)
- Barbara Michael: I believe the vegetables, other than potatoes, which could have nourished the Irish, were taken from...
- “TO BE A HEDONIST WITH BAD TASTE…” (1)
Meta
For a long time I wasn’t a big fan of Tom Bombadil. As a matter of making the plot logical and the characters’ development make sense, however, he is a very useful device. The four hobbits are just venturing out into the world for the first time and would likely get themselves into trouble and would need help – Bombadil is a source of assistance as they develop competence, and there are reasons to keep them from encountering Aragorn or Gandalf again.
A deus ex machina is a useful thing for a writer.
Looking at it now, I had forgotten that Frodo still has nightmares, even in the safety of Bombadil’s home. An early sign that Frodo will be irrevocably damaged by this task.