CONCRETE OR WOOD?

CONCRETE OR WOOD? In the article I linked to yesterday on the remodeling of Saarinen’s library at the University of Chicago Law School, I counted five references to the use of wood to make the new interior more comfortable. One of the drawbacks for the architecture of the sixties is that reinforced concrete was a fashionable material for buildings. One reason it was fashionable was the enormous influence of the architect Le Corbusier, who is quoted here as saying, “I have given my life to concrete.” This review of an exhibit in Poland begins: “Concrete Legacy: From Le Corbusier to the Homeboys focuses on concrete block housing as one of the gravest consequences of Modernist architectural thought. Large, prefabricated concrete slabs, used in entire housing developments, individual blocks and individual dwellings, continue to determine living conditions for, and shape the thinking of, millions of people.” Not surprisingly, people don’t like interior concrete walls. Architects seemed to know this. The interior walls of concrete buildings were often striated to evoke the feeling that wood gives.

This entry was posted in Architecture. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to CONCRETE OR WOOD?

  1. Howard Johnson says:

    Not necessarily modernist: Think Amsterdam and its canals lined with splendid buildings and pretty, gabled houses. Like all other buildings in Holland, the interior walls of those buildings and houses are made of brick or concrete since the water and weather prevents the use of wood construction. And what does a Dutch family want you to say on entering their house — that it is behaaglijk — cozy. But I do agree that Dutch housing may help shape Dutch thought. But that’s a different subject.

  2. Philip says:

    Remembering all those Greenwich village unplastered walls, I think of brick interior walls as cozy too. But I found all those massive concrete walls in the sixties very depressing, although where there were such walls, there was usually no attempt at other amenities for the people inside the building. I’d love to hear your thoughts on Dutch housing and Dutch thought.

  3. Pingback: SAVING BRUTALIST BUILDINGS—PAUL RUDOLPH. | Pater Familias

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.