DOES PERSONALITY COME FROM NATURE OR NURTURE? Carol Tavris says in her review of Daniel Nettle’s PERSONALITY that “Behavioural-genetic studies have consistently found that the heritability of personality traits… is around 50 per cent”—that is, attributable to genetic differences. But the shared environment of the home has only a weak correlation with personality traits. “Nurture”—defined and measured broadly—has little measurable effect on personality. There is speculation that individual life events and choices account for the other fifty per cent, but I think the best way to summarize the review is that there is no agreement on the remaining fifty per cent. All this leaves a lot of room for novelists. And maybe, as I posted on here, on Colin McGinn’s view of Shakespeare, it leaves a person free in part to choose a personality.
Categories
Archives
Recent Comments
- ADAPTING GATSBY. (1)
- Mary Jane Schaefer: I think these are crucial, important decisions, what to leave out of any literary work, maybe any...
- DAMIEN HIRST—AN ART MARKET BUBBLE?. (1)
- Kate Bush: I hope you enjoy my visit to the Damien Hirst show as much as I did The Technical Impossibility of...
- THE MOST IMPORTANT EPISODE OF THE SIMPSONS ? (COMMENT). (1)
- Nick: Homer does has success as the team’s best hitter until Mr. Burns places a bet with a rival factory owner...
- THE “RIGHT TO EDIT”. (1)
- Lee: A relevant Simpsons clip.
- ULYSSES—VIRGINIA WOOLF LIKED THE BOOK, DESPISED THE AUTHOR. (3)
- A DEFENSE OF INVASIVE SPECIES. (3)
- Dick Weisfelder: Today’s Toledo Blade has an article on the importation of live Asian carp to Canada to serve...
- Lee: The downside is that red squirrels are way cuter than their gray cousins. Hitchens on the subject.
- THE OLDEST FANTASY BASEBALL LEAGUE STARTS ITS 32ND SEASON. (COMMENT). (5)
- frank martin: Have been in a an Al only Roto league since 91… started at Ohio University were we all went to...
- DEATH OF A BUMBLEBEE. (1)
- Nick: By contrast, I remember witnessing the entire thing. I was surprised by Annalisa’s reaction and...
- ANOTHER VOTE ON UMBRIDGE. (1)
- Dick Weisfelder: When I look back at one of the Potter books, it’s usually this one. There are just a lot of...
- THE SCARIEST VILLAIN IN HARRY POTTER? (1)
- Dick Weisfelder: Didn’t we all meet her somewhere in grade or high school?
- ADAPTING GATSBY. (1)
Meta
There’s a difference between environment and between individual experience.
For example, a childhood friend and I grew up in the same town, with attentive, affluent parents. This incident occurs at age 3. Let’s say my mom takes me with her while she shops at Palmer’s, an upscale grocery store, and his mom takes him with her while she shops at Stew Leonard’s, another upscale grocery store.
Now, Stew Leonard’s has all kinds of “wacky” stuff in the store that they claim is for kids – dancing animatronic milk cartons and broccoli and so forth. They also have a cow the size of the Hindenburg on the wall that will moo if you push a button.
Childhood friend might have some sort of phobia or uncertainty or something based on that event which would never have been picked up on in a study looking for “environment”.
Pingback: OCTOPUSES AND PEOPLE. | Pater Familias