MEASURING THE AMERICAN DREAM. Kids, in reading articles about income distribution you have to pay attention to measurement problems. The word “poverty” is ambiguous. Sometimes it refers to relative poverty and sometimes to absolute poverty. I think that in the article I linked to today, Professor Krugman is talking about relative poverty rather than absolute poverty. The estimate he uses, which apparently is based apparently on following a sample of parents and children, avoids one of the frustrations of comparisons of income distribution. Over a period of a generation, immigration, presumably from poorer countries, causes measurement problems. Simple comparisons of the lowest 25% thirty years apart run into the problem that after thirty years, many of the lowest quartile will include immigrants who lived in poverty in other countries, for whom we don’t have any information. Presumably a majority of these immigrants are better off than they had been, even if they are now in the bottom quartile in the United States. Following individuals doesn’t avoid measurement problems entirely, however, because new immigrants from poorer countries would make it easier for the second generation in the study to escape the bottom quartile.
Categories
Archives
Recent Comments
- ADAPTING GATSBY. (1)
- Mary Jane Schaefer: I think these are crucial, important decisions, what to leave out of any literary work, maybe any...
- DAMIEN HIRST—AN ART MARKET BUBBLE?. (1)
- Kate Bush: I hope you enjoy my visit to the Damien Hirst show as much as I did The Technical Impossibility of...
- THE MOST IMPORTANT EPISODE OF THE SIMPSONS ? (COMMENT). (1)
- Nick: Homer does has success as the team’s best hitter until Mr. Burns places a bet with a rival factory owner...
- THE “RIGHT TO EDIT”. (1)
- Lee: A relevant Simpsons clip.
- ULYSSES—VIRGINIA WOOLF LIKED THE BOOK, DESPISED THE AUTHOR. (3)
- A DEFENSE OF INVASIVE SPECIES. (3)
- Dick Weisfelder: Today’s Toledo Blade has an article on the importation of live Asian carp to Canada to serve...
- Lee: The downside is that red squirrels are way cuter than their gray cousins. Hitchens on the subject.
- THE OLDEST FANTASY BASEBALL LEAGUE STARTS ITS 32ND SEASON. (COMMENT). (5)
- frank martin: Have been in a an Al only Roto league since 91… started at Ohio University were we all went to...
- DEATH OF A BUMBLEBEE. (1)
- Nick: By contrast, I remember witnessing the entire thing. I was surprised by Annalisa’s reaction and...
- ANOTHER VOTE ON UMBRIDGE. (1)
- Dick Weisfelder: When I look back at one of the Potter books, it’s usually this one. There are just a lot of...
- THE SCARIEST VILLAIN IN HARRY POTTER? (1)
- Dick Weisfelder: Didn’t we all meet her somewhere in grade or high school?
- ADAPTING GATSBY. (1)
Meta
I’m learning more and more that criticism in academia should not be accepted at face value necessarily. It is valuable to have interpretations of evidence, and new conclusions that often provide a lot of insight. However, sometimes the conclusions drawn are simply false, misleading, or unconvincing.